- Settlement money is owed to your client, not the firm, and follows different rules from client fees: go through opposing counsel, and handle funds the firm receives under trust-account rules.
- Put the payer's own references (case caption, defendant, installment number, opposing counsel) on every request so their AP team can match it, within any confidentiality terms.
- Track each settlement installment as its own promise with an owner, and record the agreement's notice, cure and default terms alongside it.
- Use a written escalation ladder where finance prepares and attorneys decide and sign; payment-term changes, waivers and enforcement stay with counsel and the client.
- Automate reminders, contact checks and first drafts within your confidentiality and supervision duties; keep people on counsel calls, signatures and exceptions.
Take a customer we worked with: a contingency-fee employment law firm with hundreds of settlements a month moving into the payment stage. Very little of that money was owed by the firm's own clients. It was owed by defendants, and the payments ran through the defendants' lawyers. Attorneys stepped into collections only when an account had gone very stale, and even then the letters were drafted by the team. The collections staff weren't losing control of receivables; they simply couldn't keep up, and leadership had no appetite to add headcount.
That is the real shape of law firm collections for many practices: two distinct collection workflows, rules that limit who can talk to whom, and a lot of lawyer time at risk. Collections works when finance runs a documented process that attorneys set up and supervise: know who owes, reach the person who actually pays, track every installment, and escalate on rules. Attorneys then step into individual matters where legal judgment, the client's authorization or a lawyer's action changes the outcome. Automate the administrative work, not the legal judgment.
This guide walks through that process, with links to deeper playbooks for each step.
Who Owes a Law Firm Money — and Why It Changes How You Collect
The money a law firm is waiting on usually comes from two directions, and they are different kinds of claims.
Your own clients. Hourly fees, flat fees, retainer top-ups and case costs. These are debts owed to the firm itself (advance payments not yet earned sit in trust until they are). This is the side most guides cover: engagement letters, billing cadence, payment plans, and what to do when a client stops paying.
The other side. Settlement or judgment money a defendant owes your client, often paid in installments and usually coordinated through opposing counsel. The defendant's obligation runs to the client, not to the firm; the firm's interest is the fee its engagement agreement gives it out of that recovery. For a contingency practice, though, this is where much of the revenue sits, so the firm runs the follow-up on the client's behalf.
The two look alike on an aging report. They aren't.
| Your own client | The other side | |
|---|---|---|
| Who you contact | The client (or their AP team, for a business client) | Opposing counsel first; the defendant's AP only with counsel's consent |
| Your leverage | The relationship, the engagement letter and, ultimately, a fee claim | The client's settlement agreement or judgment, and the enforcement options it allows |
| Where the money lands | The operating account once fees are earned; unearned advances go to trust | Often the firm's trust account first; sometimes paid directly or through payroll |
| Rules that matter most | Confidentiality; fee-dispute rules; consumer-collection law for individual clients | Rules on contacting represented parties; trust-account rules; the client's authority over the settlement |
The trust-account point changes what "collected" means. Settlement funds paid to the firm on a client's behalf go into the firm's trust account; under Rule 1.15 in most states, undisputed amounts are paid out promptly and disputed amounts stay in trust. (Some settlements are paid directly to the client instead, or partly through the defendant's payroll, depending on the agreement.) So the collection job on the settlement side is getting the other side to pay, on schedule, against the client's agreement. The firm's fee becomes the firm's money only after that. Your leverage is the agreement and the remedies it allows, not a credit line you can cut off, and decisions about those remedies sit with the attorney and the client.
The rest of this guide follows the settlement side as the main thread, because that's where most guides go quiet, and notes where client fees differ.
Ground Rules Before Anyone Picks Up the Phone
This isn't legal advice. The references below are to the ABA Model Rules; your state's version may differ in wording and numbering, so check it, or ask your ethics counsel, before you set the process.
When the payer is represented: go through counsel
Under the ABA Model Rules and most state versions, a lawyer may not communicate about the matter with a party known to be represented, without that party's lawyer's consent (Rule 4.2). That limit also covers staff or vendors contacting the other side for the firm: a lawyer can't do through someone else what the rule bars them from doing directly. A finance coordinator emailing a defendant about a late installment is, for this purpose, the firm.
Lawyers must also make reasonable efforts so that staff and outside vendors act consistently with the lawyer's own ethics duties (Rule 5.3). If you outsource part of collections, the vendor's scripts and emails are part of your process.
The safest practice: get opposing counsel's consent (ideally in writing) before your team contacts the defendant's AP, copy counsel, and stick to payment logistics: amounts, dates, references, remittance details. Anything about the merits, the agreement's terms or a dispute goes back to the lawyers. Whether a particular AP contact is covered at all, and how things change once the case has closed, varies by state, which is why "get consent first" is the sensible default.
When the payer is your own client
Chasing your own client raises different questions.
- Confidentiality. Most states let a lawyer reveal client information reasonably necessary to establish a fee claim, and no more; the paragraph number varies by state (in the Model Rules it's Rule 1.6(b)(5)). Your reminders, and any outside collector, should get the minimum: amount, dates, invoice numbers, not the story of the case.
- Debt-collection law. The FDCPA generally doesn't govern a firm collecting its own fees in its own name. It can reach the firm if it collects under a name that suggests a third party is involved, and an outside agency collecting consumer debts from individual clients is usually covered itself; hiring one doesn't by itself make the firm a debt collector. Lawyers who regularly collect consumer debts for others are covered; the Supreme Court said so in Heintz v. Jenkins. Whether a debt is a consumer debt turns on what it was for (personal, family or household purposes), not just on whether the payer is a person; settlement payments owed by a business defendant generally aren't consumer debts, and if the payer is an individual, check with counsel. State collection laws can be broader, and some also cover creditors collecting their own debts, so check yours.
- Suing a client. Malpractice insurers warn that suing a client for fees often draws a malpractice counterclaim. Many state bars run fee arbitration or mediation, and some make it more than an option: California, for example, requires a lawyer to give the client a notice of the right to fee arbitration before suing over fees, and to take part if the client chooses arbitration. Review your state's fee-dispute rules before any suit or agency referral, and treat a fee suit as the last rung, not the next one.
Find the Person Who Actually Pays
A late settlement installment often isn't a refusal at all; the request simply never reached someone who could act on it.
At the firm we worked with, invoices carried the client's name but not opposing counsel's. When a bill landed in the defendant's accounting department, nobody there could match it to anything they recognized, so it was set aside or thrown away. And one opposing lawyer often represented several defendants across different matters, but nobody tracked those links, so the same lawyer got uncoordinated requests from different people at the firm.
Two fixes go a long way:
- Put on every payment request what their side can match. Case caption and number, the defendant's name (their client), the date of the settlement agreement, the installment number and amount, and opposing counsel's name. Their AP team pays against their references, not yours. Include only what's needed to match the payment, within any confidentiality terms in the settlement, sealing or protective orders, and limits on client data.
- Track opposing counsel as a relationship, not a line item. Keep one record per opposing lawyer with every matter and defendant attached. One call to a lawyer who handles four of your open settlements can clear four items, and it's a better conversation than four separate chasers.
When you do have to call around to find the right contact, many first calls land at a front desk. Here is a collections call script for when you reach the switchboard, including how to find the AP contact and log what you learn so the next call starts further along.
Match the Channel to Who's on the Other End
There are three very different recipients in law firm collections, and they respond to different things.
- Opposing counsel is a repeat counterparty. You'll deal with the same lawyers next month and next year. Tone matters as much as timing, and a short, precise note usually works better than a stack of automated reminders.
- A corporate defendant's AP team works from references, portals and payment runs. They need the right documents, in the right format, sent to the right inbox in time for their cycle.
- Individual clients need plain language and easy ways to pay: a link, a clear amount, a date.
Email works well for some of these recipients and poorly for others; when a payer doesn't answer email, switch to a call rather than sending the same message louder. If you plan to add text messages, check consent requirements first; federal (TCPA) and some state rules can apply to texts.
For the message itself, here is how to write a past due invoice email to someone you'll work with again, with examples and a review step before anything goes out.
Keep Settlement Payment Plans on Schedule
Settlements are often paid over months, so one settlement can mean a dozen separate due dates. Give each installment its own amount, its own date, an owner on your side and a contact on theirs, rather than leaving it as a line in a letter.
Record the agreement's default terms alongside the schedule, too: any required written notice of default and who must receive it, cure periods, acceleration or late-interest clauses, and enforcement deadlines. A reminder email is not a formal default notice, and an automated escalation shouldn't stand in for the notices and steps the agreement requires.
The routine itself is simple. Before the due date, confirm the details with the payer's side. On the due date, check whether the money arrived. If it didn't, follow up the same week, find out why, and either get a new committed date or make a deliberate decision to escalate. Finance can track and chase installments, but agreeing to a later date than the agreement allows, changing payment terms or waiving a default goes to the attorney, within what the client has authorized: the settlement is the client's. For the detailed sequence, see what to do in the first 72 hours after a broken promise to pay.
Watch how your systems record the schedule. If your practice-management or accounting tool books a multi-payment settlement as one invoice with one due date, aging shows the whole balance as either not yet due or badly late, and nobody can tell from the report which installment was actually missed. Teams end up keeping the real schedule in a spreadsheet next to the system. If that sounds familiar, here is how to reconcile installment balances that don't match so the ledger reflects the payment plan.
One more wrinkle for employment practices: when part of a settlement is paid as wages, it may run through the defendant's payroll, which can add steps and timing to each installment.
An Escalation Ladder That Keeps Lawyers on Their Cases
Lawyers are the most expensive people you can put on a late payment, and also the only people who can take some of the steps. The answer is to decide in advance which rungs need a lawyer and how much of their time each rung takes.
| Rung | Who owns it | Typical trigger (set your own) | Lawyer time |
|---|---|---|---|
| 1. Reminders and calls | Finance / collections team | Installment due, or a few days late | None |
| 2. Counsel-to-counsel request | Finance prepares; attorney approves or sends | Missed installment still open after the first follow-ups | Minutes to review |
| 3. Formal letter on attorney letterhead | Finance drafts; attorney reviews and signs | Second missed installment, or no reply after a set number of touches | Short review and signature |
| 4. Attorney action | Attorney | Letter ignored, or a clear refusal | Real case time |
At rung 4, the action depends on the debtor. For a settlement, counsel chooses the route with the client: a motion to enforce in the original court (only where that court kept jurisdiction to enforce the settlement; a federal court often doesn't once the case is dismissed, unless its order says so), a separate breach-of-contract action, or judgment enforcement if the settlement was entered as a consent judgment. Which applies depends on the settlement terms, the court and the applicable law. For unpaid client fees, it's fee arbitration, an outside agency or, last, a suit, after any notice your state's fee-dispute rules require.
A few principles make the ladder work:
- Triggers are firm policy, not law. Write them down (days past due, missed installments, unanswered touches) and apply them the same way every time.
- Finance prepares, attorneys decide and sign. At the firm we worked with, the team prepared letters and the groundwork for filings (payment histories, missed installments, correspondence) under attorney supervision, and everything went out under the attorney's name after review. That's the model: finance and support staff handle the administrative work and preliminary drafts, while legal analysis, strategy and anything filed with a court stay with the attorney, who reviews, approves and is responsible for them.
- Budget lawyer time per rung. If rung 3 regularly takes an hour of attorney time, the draft isn't ready when it reaches them.
What a demand letter is, and how it differs from reminders and referrals, is covered in our demand letter guide; the collection letter guide covers wording and templates. This ladder stays at the level of who does what, and when.
Scaling Collections Without Adding People
At hundreds of settlements a month, the volume grows faster than the team. The firm we worked with had a sizable collections team and no interest in growing it; the view from leadership was that managing one more vendor beat managing a bigger team.
That's a reasonable position, and it points to a clear split.
Automate the repetitive layer:
- Installment schedules and due-date reminders
- Contact checks: is this the right person, and the right address, for this matter?
- First drafts of follow-ups and formal letters
- Status per matter: which installment, which rung, who owns the next step
Keep humans on:
- Calls with opposing counsel, where the relationship matters
- Attorney review and signature at rungs 3 and 4
- Exceptions: disputes, hardship requests, anything touching the agreement's terms
Daylit's AI agents for accounts receivable help with that repetitive layer: drafting collection emails for your team to review before anything goes out, and flagging contacts that look wrong for an invoice so you can reach the right person. Payment-plan and installment tracking is coming soon.
Whichever tool you use, a law firm has duties a typical business doesn't. Before adding AI or any third-party collections technology, check it against your confidentiality and supervision obligations; ABA Formal Opinion 512 (2024) covers lawyers' use of generative AI. Ask how client and matter data is stored, used and retained, keep access limited to the matters each person needs, keep attorney review on anything legally significant, and get client consent where your rules require it.
What to Measure Each Month
A short set of numbers tells you whether the process works, without benchmarking against anyone else:
- Days from signed settlement to cash in trust, by matter type
- Share of installments paid on schedule
- First-contact hit rate: how often the first request reaches someone who can pay
- Accounts at each rung of the escalation ladder
- Attorney hours spent on collections
Watch the trend rather than a target. If attorney hours fall while on-schedule installments hold steady, the ladder is doing its job.
Putting It Together
Law firm collections gets easier once you separate the two workflows, your own fees and your clients' settlements, and give each its own path. Know the ground rules before anyone calls. Put the payer's references on every request and track opposing counsel across matters. Match the channel to the recipient. Treat every installment as a promise. Escalate on a written ladder where finance prepares and attorneys decide and sign. Then automate the repetitive layer, so the team you have can keep up and your lawyers can stay on their cases.
Can our finance team contact the defendant directly about a late settlement payment?
If the defendant is represented, the safest course is to go through opposing counsel. Rule 4.2 and most state versions bar a lawyer from contacting a represented party about the matter without their lawyer's consent, and that covers staff acting for the firm. Get counsel's consent (ideally in writing), copy them, and keep to payment logistics.
Does the FDCPA apply when a law firm collects its own fees?
Generally not when the firm collects its own fees in its own name. It can apply if the firm collects under a name that suggests a third party, or regularly collects consumer debts for others, and an outside agency collecting consumer debts is usually covered itself. State collection laws can be broader, and some cover creditors collecting their own debts, so check yours.
When should an attorney get involved in collections?
Attorneys set up and supervise the process from the start, then step into individual matters at defined rungs: typically to review and sign a formal letter, to decide on any change to a settlement's payment terms, and to choose and take legal action when that letter is ignored. Write the triggers into policy so attorneys aren't pulled in case by case.
Should a law firm send unpaid client fees to a collection agency?
It can. Many state ethics opinions allow it with limits: share only the minimum client information, stay responsible for the agency's conduct, and check your state's ethics opinions and fee-dispute rules before you refer an account; some states require a notice of the client's right to fee arbitration first.



